Wednesday Wines – Episode 304 – Bolgheri Beauties & Other Musings

Bolgheri Booklet2023 Ornellaia was released yesterday to much fanfare.  Various wine writers have praised this wine greatly, with scores ranging from 96-98/100.  It is being called ‘the most affordable 98-point Ornellaia on the market’.  The release price is (just) £848 per 6 bottles in bond, down from last year’s £925 per 6 bottles in bond.  The last time Ornellaia received 98 points (from some bright spark) was the 2016 vintage, which now apparently trades at £975 – £1300 per 6 bottles in bond according to Wine-Searcher.

This is all well and good. But it is not factually true.

A 98/100 is a Jukes 19.5/20, and 96/100 is a Jukes 19/20, and my score for 2023 Ornellaia is a bright and shiny gold-medal-equivalent of 18.5/20, or in new money, 95/100.

I noted this time last year that 2022 Ornellaia, which was released at £925 per 6 bottles in bond, can now be found for anything from £800 per 6 bottles in bond to the original release price of £925 per 6 bottles in bond.  And here is my note – “Labelled the vintage of ‘Determination’, the warm weather led to low yields, small bunches and berries, and what winemakers, in hushed tones, call ‘challenges’.  As I ease into my 38th vintage in wine, it becomes stark-staringly obvious that so-called challenging vintages make far more interesting wines than easy ones!  In challenging vintages, winemakers and viticulture teams truly earn their hefty salaries, doubling down on the details and becoming forensic about their approach to their duties.  This happened in 2022.  The fruit here is buoyant, toothsome, ripe and friendly, as it appears to work hard to impress the taster. And it achieves its goal.  This is a wonderfully urbane wine with magnetic charm, a slowly revolving kaleidoscope of red and black fruit on the palate, and a fine-grained finish.  This is an elegant, perfectly tailored Ornellaia, designed for those whose lives deserve moments of calm reflection.  It will give great pleasure and joy early in its life and also stand the test of time.  I awarded this wine a score of 19.5+/20.”

As you can see, I rate the 2022 much higher than the more expensive 2023.  Once again, the wine world makes little sense, but I can assure you the 2022 is a stunning wine, truly worthy of a 98/100 score.  If you have money to spend on Ornellaia, I would not hesitate to buy the 2022 vintage now at £800!

Or don’t.  The timing of the annual Bolgheri Vintage Release tasting was perfect this year.  I take my hat off to the organisers from the official body and also to Nelson Pari and Federico Moccia, who PR this event into life with unbridled energy and positivity.  I tasted 36 wines from the 2023 vintage, including the aforementioned 2023 Ornellaia and 2023 Sassicaia, which was the standout wine of the session, earning a perfect 20/20 score.  You can read my detailed article on this peerless creation here.

SASSICAIA 2023

And Sassicaia was not the only wine that gained a 17.5/20 (equivalent to a High Silver or 91/100) or higher score at this event.  For a rundown of the nine wines I feel offered superb value and terrific balance, please read on.  You can search for these online, and I can guarantee they will bring enormous pleasure.

But before I list my favourites, I must point out that the ‘failures’, and there were many, were wines with numerous defects and in some cases faults.  I can’t believe that in this day and age, no fewer than eight of the 36 wines failed to register a score above 15.5/20, or a bog-standard bronze medal.  This is inexcusable in a region that prides itself internationally on excellence and acumen.

Over-oaking, late picking (if it tastes ripe on the vine, it is overripe!), doughnut wines (those with no middle), weediness, cruel over-extraction and multiple combinations of these failures were far too evident.  I found myself seeking out wines with any semblance of balance, and if this was achieved, an attractive taste, but even these two traits were rare.  Granted, some of the terroir in this part-noble region is simply stunning, but much of it is referred to as the ‘vegetable patch’ by those in the know, and the wines tasted like it.

So, rant over, onto the successful wines, all worthy of attention (listed in the order of the booklet).  These all gained ‘High Silver’ – ‘Gold’ medal scores in my notes.   After the wine name, I have listed the UK distributor and an email contact, which might be useful if you are a wine trade buyer.  These details are all taken directly from the booklet provided.

2023 Caccia Al Piano, Bolgheri Superiore (Ripley Wines, info@ripley-wines.com).

2023 Castello di Bolgheri, Bolgheri Superiore (Berry Bros. & Rudd, bbr@bbr.com).

2023 Ornellaia, Bolgheri Superiore (MMD, valeria.maffeis@mmfltd.co.uk).

2023 Sondraia, Poggio Al Tesora, Bolgheri Superiore (Liberty Wines, angelica.antonini@libertywines.co.uk).

2023 Guado Al Tasso, Tenuta Guado Al Tasso, Bolgheri Superiore (Berkmann Wine Cellars, sophie.mclean@bermann.co.uk).

2023 Sassicaia, Tenuta San Guido, Bolgheri Sassicaia (Armit Wines, trade@armitwines.co.uk).

2023 Camarcanda, Ca’Marcanda, Bolgheri Rosso (Hatch Mansfield, info@hatch.co.uk).

2023 Le Macchiole, Bolgheri Rosso (Lea & Sandeman, sales@leaandsandeman.co.uk).

2023 noi 4, Tenuta Sette Cieli, Bolgheri Rosso (Swig Wines, robin@swig.co.uk).

FINE