Wednesday Wines – Episode 277 – Great Value Chianti & Rosso di Montalcino
I recently tasted a collection of top-flight Chianti and Rosso di Montalcino to find some stunners that don’t break the bank. Here are the very finest wines.

2023 Chianti Superiore, Poggiotondo (£16.67, www.northandsouthwines.co.uk; £16.99, www.thefinewinecompany.co.uk; £18.20, www.shelvedwine.com).
This beautiful Poggiotondo wine is organically grown, and it is a structured and fruit-dense wine. Plums, mulberries, red cherries and layers of discreet spice invade the senses, and by contrast to the happy-go-lucky, youthful 2024 vintage wine below, this is a more luxurious and intense wine. Having said this, the tannins have already melted away, so the fruit is unencumbered and silky, making this a thrilling Chianti with waves of juicy fruits of the forest flavours tempered by crisp acidity. The balance throughout is incredible, and, like its stablemates, the value is extraordinary.
2024 Chianti, Organic, Poggiotondo (£19.00, www.akeandhumphris.co.uk).
Screwcap-sealed, organic and under £20: what more could you wish for? Well, there is more. World-famous wine consultant Alberto Antonini makes this wine from his home estate. Just that alone would rock the earth beneath any savvy wine lover. But, of course, this is not enough. These are just details, and as interesting and vital as they are, it is the taste that is all-important. The perfume, flavour and finish of this crowd-pleasing creation are all seamless, enchanting and immediate. This is the sort of wine you could pour by the flagon at your local Italian trattoria, and every person in the restaurant would be smiling. It is a work of genius to carefully remove astringency, unwanted earthiness and raw edges from a wine, before putting it gently into the bottle such that the Sangiovese grape appears civilised, engaging and conversational. This is what Alberto and his family have done with this gloriously uplifting wine.
2023 Chianti Rufina, Selvapiana (£21.99, reduced to £19.99 each in a case of 6 bottles, www.thewinereserve.co.uk).
This is the second and final screw-cap-sealed wine in this piece, and it is a year older than the Poggiotondo, and a little darker and spicier, too. It is also slightly more structured and a little drier and crunchier on the finish. You ought to drink this with food, when it comes alive, but I like to assess wine without, so I can see deeper into the core of the flavour, and this is a handsome, swaggering fellow. I know that thousands of fans look no further when they see the name Selvapiana on a wine list, and they would be right to stick to what they know. This is because the reputation forged by this noble estate gives it the right to attract attention and a duty to impress in the glass. It does not fail to reward. You will find countless references to this estate in my many years of writing about wine, and what pleases me more than I can say is that you can still buy this brilliant, hearty, and distinguished Chianti for twenty quid!
2022 Chianti Classico, Dievole £26.98, (www.ahadleigh-wine.com).
At three years of age, you might expect this wine to be well into its stride, but there is a degree of tension here that makes you stop and reassess the situation. It made me grab a decanter and contemplate logging onto Deliveroo (for a speedy lasagna delivery)! This is a firm, ripe, herbal-tinged wine with a muscular core. It needs a main course and/or time to mellow. One thing is clear: this is a lot of wine for the money, and with two more years (which I think will be the target), it will become a grand wine for a moderate spend!
2023 Chianti Classico, Terre di Cresci, Poggiotondo (£27.00, www.valvonacrolla.co.uk).
This wine elevates the Poggiotondo story to the next level of complexity and definition. Again organic, this time the fruit comes from the high-altitude area of Cresci, and it is aged in large, untoasted oak barrels. The result is a highly perfumed wine with a sour cherry theme, stunning definition and a soothing, long, savoury finish. The tannins are present, but refined, and it is drinking beautifully now. While the price tips up a few pounds, the intellect and detail found here are astounding. This is the expert’s choice from the Poggiotondo stable, and, like the other two wines, it continues to offer staggering value. Start here if you are already familiar with the entry-level styles of Chianti and want to be amazed at the style and definition of a thoroughbred, albeit one that is already drinking and doesn’t cost the earth.
2023 Rosso di Montalcino, Fossacolle (£28.20, www.shelvedwine.com).
The first of two Rossos comes from an estate with one foot in the past and one firmly planted in the present. This is a glossy, bold style that shows a darker template of fruit than all the Chiantis in this review, and it also presents a riper, fuller palate. It is a square-shouldered wine with a 14.5% alcohol level. There is a plushness here that is indulgent and seductive, and the combination of French and Slavonian oak brings added complexity and a sense of grandeur to proceedings. Despite its youth, this is already drinking, making this an incredibly and keenly priced useful Rosso!
2022 Chianti Classico, Fèlsina Berardenga (£28.95, www.nywines.co.uk).
Fèlsina is a legendary estate, and this wine, while it is not a single vineyard creation, or a Riserva, or special bottling of any kind, behaves like a ‘grand vin’. This is a formal, traditionally shaped Chianti of the highest order, and it is actively youthful, challenging and closed. It demands time, and unlike many estate wines at this age, which drink well, this needs a further three or four years to find equilibrium. This is a fabulous, tense, and toned Chianti, and it is another example of epic value. But you must not be tempted to peek too soon. It is not tannic per se, but remarkably introverted.
2023 Rosso di Montalcino, San Polo (£32.00, www.valvonacrolla.co.uk).
The second Rosso could not be more different from the Fossacolle version. San Polo is pale, bright, and resonant in the glass. It is perfumed, ethereal and hauntingly refreshing, and with a 13.5% alcohol framework, it is a more fleet-footed wine than the previous wine, too. With sour cherry fruit and a lean, rakish finish, this wine shows that Montalcino wines do not have to be too muscular or oak-soaked. By contrast, they can be shimmeringly pretty and refined.
2022 Chianti Classico, Isole e Olena (£32.99, www.nywines.co.uk).
At the top of this pile, while keeping a firm grip on price and value, sits Isole e Olena. It seems to be, having tasted ten other wines, that this glorious Chianti takes all the favourable and attractive elements from this set of brilliant wines and weaves them into the most extraordinary cape of fruit, which is then draped around the shoulders of this very wine. Isole has long been a beacon of excellence in Tuscany, and this venerable estate appears to bottle magical Sangiovese at will. This 2022 is seamless, swirling, infinitely complex and lip-smackingly well-balanced. It is fast approaching its drinking period, thanks to its near-perfect equilibrium.
2021 Chianti Classiso, Filetta di Lamole, Fontodi (£33.50, www.nywines.co.uk).
Coming from the Lamole area, situated at 600m, this is a wonderfully sleek and silky wine with little oak interference and a long, smooth, savoury finish. Unlike the more structured wines and those with decisive oak details, this beautiful wine is simply a siren song of the Lamole terroir with its stunningly aromatic signature. The nose is as enveloping as the palate is pure, and at four years of age, this wine is hitting the peak of its powers, where it will remain for a few more years with ease. Once again, the value here is terrific, underlining the glaringly obvious fact that you do not have to seek out Riservas to have fun!
2022 Chianti Classico, Fontodi (£34.50, www.valvonacrolla.co.uk).
Fontodi’s estate wine, even with three years under its belt, is still a baby. This wine is the slowest-moving and most deliberate in this collection, and it is crammed full of elite, infinitely detailed Sangiovese. While the oak has been absorbed, I can sense the girders of control that maintain the scale and grandeur of this wine’s cathedral of flavour. This is the second wine (with Fèlsina), which ought not to be opened for a couple of years, and when you do, you will experience chapters of knowledge, understanding and skill in the glass!
