Vindependents 2019 Burgundy En Primeur Collection – my notes and scores

Vindependents 2019 Burgundy En Primeur Collection

See the A-Z of Vindependent Wine Merchants below and please do contact marketing manager Louise Vaux at or your local merchant if you are interested in reserving any of these wines.

Domaine Christian Bellang & Fils

2019 Bourgogne Chardonnay, Sous la Velle, Domaine Christian Bellang & Fils           

Creamy, herbal and quite forward, there is nothing out of place here and it does its job well.  16.5/20

2019 Meursault, Domaine Christian Bellang & Fils

More robust and structured and, as this is a barrel sample, there is a fair amount of oak and traction here, but this is a very well-made wine and the balance is spot on.  17/20

Les Parcellaires de Saulx

2019 Saint-Aubin Blanc, 1er Cru Sur Gamay, Les Parcellaires de Saulx  

This is a little ‘ripe’ and a little lacklustre on the palate and this makes this wine fall a little flat.  15/20

Domaine Sylvain Dussort

2019 Bourgogne Côte d’Or Blanc, Cuvée des Ormes, Domaine Sylvain Dussort

Very extracted and powerful for a BB and rather oaky and hard, too.  This is a personal thing, but don’t buy this wine if you are not a fan of muscular white wines and, equally, if you like structure and weight, you will love it!  16/20

2019 Meursault, Vieilles Vignes, Domaine Sylvain Dussort         

Another chunky, fruit-concentrated wine, this style is rather overbearing and not for me, but the wine is certainly impactful.  16/20

2019 Meursault, Le Limozin, Domaine Sylvain Dussort  

Like the other two above, this is a hugely impactful and raw style with little polish and finesse and while I am not a fan of this style, there is a lot of action going on in the glass!  16.5/20

Domaine Rémi Jeanniard

2019 Morey-Saint-Denis, Domaine Rémi Jeanniard

Accurate, mineral-soaked, cherry-themed and rather nicely balanced, this is not a muscular Morey, but a jolly nice, genial wine.  17/20

2019 Gevrey-Chambertin, Vieilles Vignes, Domaine Rémi Jeanniard

A little more backward and closed than the Morey, this is an earthier creation with less obvious, generous fruit and it needs a little longer to round out, but it will be an honest wine in due course.  17/20

Domaine Catherine et Claude Maréchal

2019 Bourgogne Aligoté, Domaine Catherine & Claude Maréchal         

Simple, clean, slimline and yet very long and rewarding, this is a lovely, classy wine with great balance.  17/20

2019 Savigny-lès-Beaune Blanc, Domaine Catherine & Claude Maréchal

Classic Maréchal with herbal notes interwoven with the mineral spice and citrus tones, this is a fairly powerful white and it has the stuffing to live for a few years, but I would be tempted to catch it earlier rather than later while the energy and acidity is still firm and enticing.  17.5/20

2019 Chorey-lès-Beaune, Domaine Catherine & Claude Maréchal

Very bright and evocative on the nose and with masses of energy and attack, this is a superb Chorey.  Still quite tense and firm on the finish, please be patient because there is a lot of fun to be had here in a few years.  17.5/20

2019 Auxey-Duresses, Domaine Catherine & Claude Maréchal 

Delicious and very expressive, this is a lovely, ripe Auxey and it shows off Maréchal’s skill in this village.  High tone and floral, this is a beautifully aromatic Pinot.   17.5/20

Domaine Gaëlle et Jérôme Meunier

2019 Rully Blanc, Domaine Gaëlle et Jérôme Meunier     

Nice, bright, clean and resonant, this is a fresh wine without the severe acidity often associated with this appellation and it is forward-drinking, too.  16.5/20

2019 Mercurey Blanc, 1er Cru, Domaine Gaëlle et Jérôme Meunier       

Accurate, tense and mineral on the palate, I like this wine and it is clean and bright without too much fat and oiliness on the mid-palate and this is refreshing in this vintage.  The finish is citrusy and uplifting and this makes it all very pleasurable indeed.  17.5/20

2019 Mercurey Rouge, 1er Cru, Domaine Gaëlle et Jérôme Meunier      

This is a nice, juicy wine with a medium-weight palate and an accurate red cherry nose.  Nice and ripe, with a smooth finish, this is a forward wine and one which looks nicely balanced already. 17/20

Domaine André Moingeon & Fils

2019 Saint-Aubin, 1er Cru Les Frionnes, Domaine André Moingeon & Fils

Quite firm and oaky on the nose and rather square and unyielding on the palate, this is a wine which makes itself heard and it certainly rewards with a lot of action.  Not a ‘fine wine’ but an opinionated and rewarding creation.  17/20

2019 Chassagne-Montrachet Blanc, Domaine André Moingeon & Fils

Classy and controlled, this is a very tidy wine with all of the required elements in place and in addition to this, there is a long finish and great precision. I am impressed.  17.5/20

Domaine Henri & Gilles Remoriquet

2019 Bourgogne-Hautes Côtes de Nuits Rouge, Domaine Henri & Gilles Remoriquet

A little rustic and dry, but certainly ripe and not too tense, this is a decent wine but it lacks flair.  15.5/20

2019 Nuits-Saint-Georges, Les Allots, Domaine Remoriquet      

Perfumed and also very accurate for this lieu-dit, this is a rather intriguing wine with wildflower notes and a long, even finish.  Dry and firm, the tannins here are neatly arranged and they will propel this wine forwards for a decade or more.  17.5/20

Domaine Réné Cacheux

2019 Chambolle-Musigny, Domaine Réné Cacheux        

This is a bold Chambolle with a dense flavour and while it is a touch atypical, there is a lot of depth here and a slight over-ripe feel which is not unpleasant!  It will age slowly and provide rather flamboyant drinking!  17/20

2019 Vosne-Romanée, Domaine Réné Cacheux   

Dark, spicy, earthy and deep this is an impressive wine for a village level and I very much like the fruit tone which is plummy and black-cherry-soaked.  There are quite frisky tannins here, too, which will keep this wine fit and tidy for a good decade!  18/20

Domaine Billard Père et Fils

2019 Saint-Romain, La Combe Bazin, Domaine Billard Père et Fils       

Slightly oxidised and the colour doesn’t look fresh either, I have not scored this wine.

2019 Saint-Aubin, 1er Cru Vignes Moingeon, Domaine Billard Père et Fils       

This is a slightly old-fashioned wine with some creaminess and a little touch of old oak and this makes it less energetic and enjoyable on the palate.  The shape, size and length is all correct, but I would like a slightly brighter feel throughout.  15.5/20

2019 Auxey-Duresses, Domaine Billard Père et Fils         

Oddly pale and rather confected this is a difficult wine to enjoy.  15/20

Domaine Réyane & Pascal Bouley

2019 Bourgogne Côte d’Or Pinot Noir, Domaine Réyane & Pascal Bouley       

Rather wild and a little too dry, this is a wine with plenty of life ahead of it, but it looks a little coarse and introverted now.  Hard to assess, I would not be surprised if it comes good, but for now, I am being cautious with my score.  15.5/20

2019 Volnay, Domaine Réyane & Pascal Bouley  

There is more flair and impact here and this has all of the makings of a fine Volnay.  Not too big, nor too oaky, there is plenty of fruit here and tart tannins, too, and this should harmonise nicely in five or six years.  17/20

2019 Volnay 1er Cru Robardelle, Domaine Réyane & Pascal Bouley                  

With more obvious fruit than the village wine, this is a nice step up, but I have yet to see the prices, so only trade up if this looks like it is a fair increase.  17.5/20

Domaine Olivier Guyot

2019 Marsannay, La Montagne, Domaine Olivier Guyot 

Rather agricultural and lean, this is a bit hollow and a little disappointing.  15/20

2019 Gevrey-Chambertin, En Champs, Domaine Olivier Guyot

Sadly, knowing this vineyard well and also a few examples of sublime wines made in this vintage, this is another let-down.  15/20

A-Z of participating Vindependent Members

Amps Wine Merchants tel. 01832 273502

Cambridge Wine Merchants tel. 01954 214573

Define Food and Wine tel. 01606 882101

Hennings Wine Merchants tel. 01798 872485

NY Wines tel. 01223 566744

Old Chapel Cellars  tel. 01872 270545

Planet Of The Grapes tel. 020 7405 4912

Reserve Wines tel. 0161 4380101

Sheldon’s Wine Cellars tel. 01608 661409

Taurus Wines tel. 01483 548484

The Sampler tel. 020 7225 5091

The Vineking tel. 01737 244823

WoodWinters Wines & Whiskies tel. 01786 469624